The building and contents were a total loss. On March 30, 1913, in just one week, the congregation resolved to build a new church on the old foundation according to the plans and specifications of the former church. A few changes were made, namely: to excavate a part of the area under the church to provide space for installation of a furnace, to slope the floor, to build a ladder within and without to the tower. Cleaning away the debris began immediately, and excavation began June 4th. Dedication services were held the same year on October 26.